A PIECE OF HISTORY-A SLICE OF AMERICA-OH WHAT THESE WALLS COULD TELL
The Rutherfurd Family's connection
to Allamuchy begins in the early 18th century. According to family
history, John Spratt acquired the land which would become known as Tranquility
from the Allamuchy Indians. The property passed to John Spratt's daughter Mary
Spratt and then to the Alexander Family upon her marriage to James Alexander.
Later the property passed to James and Mary Alexander's daughter, Catherine,
who married Walter Rutherfurd on December 21, 1758. From this date forward, the
property would remain in the Rutherfurd Family. Land inventories of Walter
Rutherfurd, held at the New York Historical Society, list the property as a
rental property of 460 acres under the name Allamuchy Farms. The estate later became
associated with the Stuyvesant Family name as result of the legal name change
of John Stuyvesant Rutherfurd to Rutherfurd Stuyvesant to satisfy a request in
the will of his great uncle, Peter Gerard Stuyvesant. The first Rutherfurd
Family home was built circa 1763.
Walter Rutherfurd and his wife
gave the property to their son, John as a wedding gift when he married Helena
Morris in October 1787. John and Helena Rutherfurd moved that same year to
Allamuchy Farms. Family legend explains how the property became known as
Tranquility. The legend goes that Helena Morris Rutherfurd upon arriving in
Allumuchy exhausted after a long journey from New York City having traveled
rough and arduous dirt roads, exclaimed at first sight of their new home "Ah,
this is truly Tranquility". John and Helena lived here while he served as United
States Senator representing New Jersey from 1791 to 1798. Although Rutherfurd
moved from Tranquility Farms to Trenton in 1798 when he resigned his U.S. Senate
seat, the property remained in the family and was given as a wedding gift to
his son, Robert Walter Rutherfurd, when he married Sabina Morris in 1809.
Robert Walter Rutherfurd was born at Tranquility Farms in 1788. Robert Walter
Rutherfurd lived at Tranquility Farms and died there on April 14, 1852.
Portions of the property were bequeathed to his children. It was his second
oldest son, Lewis Morris Rutherfurd that bought out his siblings and acquired
the entire property of his father. Lewis Morris and his wife, Margaret
Stuyvesant Chanler, used the home as a country home and in their later years
lived there all year round for the sake of his wife's health. Lewis Morris and
his wife made additions to the original 1763 house. Lewis Morris died on May
30, 1892 in New York City and is buried in Tranquility Cemetery beside his wife
Margaret who had died two years earlier. Lewis Morris Rutherfurd, who was an
astronomer and pioneer in celestial photography, took the first pictures of the
moon from Tranquility.
Tranquility Farms was left to the
children of Lewis Morris. His eldest son, who became Rutherfurd Stuyvesant,
bought out his siblings and began an extensive expansion of the house, tripling
the size in what became known as the Stuyvesant Mansion. Rutherfurd Stuyvesant
began an aggressive acquisition of adjoining properties and amassed an estate
of over 5,000 acres know as Tranquility Farms consisting of 20 farms and his
famous Deer Park which he used as private hunting preserved. Tranquility Farms
became famous for its Dorset sheep and its herd of Jersey, Guernsey and
Holstein cows. Tranquility Farms was also famous for its kennels which raised
pure bred Fox Terriers. The Deer Park game reserve was stocked with many deer
and elk. These animals where raised at Rutherfurd Stuyvesant's property in
Lacey Township in South New Jersey near Forked River. Tranquilty Farms was
also famous for the Ring Necked Pheasant which Rutherfurd Stuyvesant brought
from Great Britain to breed at his estate. The estate became a famous fall
retreat for New York Gilded Age Society for hunting outings.
The Stuyvesant Estate became the
repository of Rutherfurd Stuyvesant extensive collection of fifteen, sixteen, and
seventeen century armor. The entire collection was documented in a book in
1912 by Dean Bashford, curator of armor at the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
In 1902, Rutherfurd Stuyvesant's
brother, the youngest son of Lewis Morris Rutherfurd, Winthrop Chanler
Rutherfurd, after marrying Alice Morton, also decided to build a country house
in Allamuchy. He purchased adjacent lands just South of the village of
Allamuchy from his brother and third parties and built a brick home in the
Tudor/Jacobite style designed by Whitney Warren, whose is most famously know for
his masterpiece, Grand Central Station. The designs were drawn to the requests
of Mrs. Alice Morton Rutherfurd, incorporating both the Rutherfurd and Morton
Family Shields over the fire place of the main hall. The estate to become
known as Allamuchy Farms which consisted of several farms totally 1,000 acres.
Rutherfurd Stuyvesant died in Paris
on July 4, 1909 and his estate was occupied by his widow, later to be known as
Princess Alexandra Carman de Chimay and her two sons, Lewis Rutherfurd and Alan
Rutherfurd Stuyvesant. Lewis died in 1944, Princess Chimay in 1948 and Alan in
1954. The contents of the interior of the Stuyvesant Estate were auctioned off
at two auctions in beginning in 1950 and another later in the 1950s. The
mansion was unoccupied for 11 years until tragically the mansion mysteriously
burned to the ground on September 2, 1959. The estate of Tranquility Farms
remained in the family and was owned by the only surviving heir, Peter
Rutherfurd Stuyvesant, only son of Lewis Rutherfurd Stuyvesant. Peter
Stuyvesant lived in the stone house in the Deer Park until his death in 1970 at
the age of 35. The estate was put up for sale and was purchased by the State
of New Jersey in 1974 and became the core of what is known today as Allamuchy
State Park.
The brick house of Winthrop Chanler
Rutherfurd remained in the Rutherfurd Family until the death of Winthrop
Ruthefurd's second wife, Lucy Rutherfurd in July 1948. The property changed
ownership in 1949/1950 when the Sisters of Divine Charity of Staten Island, NY converted
the mansion into a retirement home for older members of their order. The
property has been known for the past half century as Villa Madonna. The Sister
of Divine Charity left Villa Madonna in 2005 and put the property up for sale.
The property was purchased in 2008 by the Allamuchy Board of Education.